Edmunds.com Tests the New Z51 Stingray Against Nissan’s GT-R

Edmunds 1Edmunds.com has done all of us a great service by test driving some of the market’s best in terms of cars, trucks and pretty much anything else that can be technically called a motor vehicle. They’ve also tested some of the supercar market’s best, and this goes for the American stuff as much as it does their international competitors.

As you already know, Corvette really is our favorite sports car, and for that simple reason, we try to hold our nation’s flagship vehicle up to an even higher standard, one that is worthy of the auto performance market on a scale that is more global now than ever.

Edmunds 4One of the most recent supercar creations to come from across the Pacific was Nissan’s flagship GT-R, a piece of Japanese auto engineering that’s proven to be as heavy and temperamental as it is fast. But what is “fast?” Everyone forms an opinion and everyone has a story behind why they deem a certain car or truck to be “fast,” but how do the numbers themselves add-up when it comes to one of our industry’s most profound cross-comparisons: GM’s new C7 Stingray and the twin-turbo GT-R that, just a few years back, put Nissan on the supercar map?

Nissan's twin-turbocharged GT-R is one of the most remarkable flagships to come out of Japan, but it's substantially heavier, more expensive and far more touchy than the Z51 Stingray for 2014.

The answer to the dangling question can be found behind the wheel of both sleds, and we’re lucky enough to have Edmunds’ Josh Jacquot and Mike Monticello to show us just how that’s done. Needless to say, the results from both the import and domestic ends were really something to see.

With its more than 3,800-pound curb weight and twin-blown, 545 horsepower 3.8-liter mill, Nissan’s ’13 GT-R has had the benefit of five model year’s worth of development, picking up more power, improved durability, and a steeper price tag along the way. However, there are some glitches that Mike Monticello was able to find within the Nissan super sled.

Among the Nissan’s biggest drawbacks are its whale-like weight and pain-in-the-ass traction control, an electronic system that at times just decides that it’s going to “magically” bomb out of nowhere. Monticello was able to observe that the 545-horse Nissan grabbed on to some massive engine speed and booked when working properly, but again this was only when “working properly.”

GM's new Stingray for 2014 is significantly lower in price than Nissan's GT-R, plus significantly lighter in weight. Not only this, but it delivers a way cooler sound when you hit the throttle!

Otherwise, Edmunds.com found that not only did GM’s current Z51 Stingray offer a better driving experience, but it did so for a substantially-lower sticker price. This, of course, was not saying anything to justify the C7’s $68,000 price tag, but in comparison to Tokyo’s $97k rice burner, GM’s Stingray was smellin’ pretty darn good!

So is the GT-R a smart buy for the performance car enthusiast who’s looking to buy a Ferrari killer for the streets? If you’re a Project JDM fan or just like Japanese muscle overall, and spending nearly $100 grand on a Nissan is your thing, then okay. But dollar-for-dollar is it the absolute “best” plan of action? The answer to that, as we’ve learned from Edmunds, is probably not!

Edmunds 8

About the author

Salvatore Alaimo

After graduating from California State University, Northridge, California, Sal Alaimo Jr. has continued with his passion of the automotive industry. Alaimo's been an auto enthusiast since his early years, and grew up learning about cars from his father, Sal Alaimo Sr. If its got a set of fat rear tires and 8-cylinders, Alaimo Jr. is all for it. Today, Alaimo Jr. brings with him a pool of enthusiasm and pride as a contributing freelance writer for Chevy Hardcore.
Read My Articles

Corvette's in your inbox.

Build your own custom newsletter with the content you love from Corvette Online, directly to your inbox, absolutely FREE!

Free WordPress Themes

We will safeguard your e-mail and only send content you request.